Hey Josh, I'm not sure why James left the band but it seemed to happen quite suddenly. The band started the Are You Ready tour in Prince George, BC. AlreadyGone was at that show & phoned our friend Laurel to say James wasn't there but there was another person playing piano. That was Bob Packwood's first show and he's been there ever since.
I do remember when it happened there was something on the home page about James leaving the band and asking the fans to respect the band's privacy with respect to the change. At the time it made me think perhaps it wasn't a happy parting but who knows.
For my money I just love what Bob Packwood adds to the band. James was a great piano player but I have to say I much prefer Bob Packwood.
Greg Keelor met Jim Cuddy and then I met you people. Serendipity is a marvellous thing.
"I guess I don't know if I believe in God but
I know a song can make you feel good once
in a while." ~Greg Keelor~